Cherry Grove Pizza in Fire Island

Not as good as it used to be.

Great spot serving not only pizza but great Italian entrees. I was just there today. Such a great lunch Food was better than ever, great service. Do not let the name fool you. It is not your average pizzeria. Amazing entrees. Can't wait to go back.

Great food. The ziti and meatballs are to die for. The tomato sauce is homemade and delicious. I'm here in Cherry Grove and I will eat dinner at Grove Pizza every single night. Always good. Always fresh. Warm Italian bread and butter served with your meal. Best food in Cherry Grove!

Consistently good food and friendly staff make this a local favorite as well as a popular tourist spot. Check out the weekday specials for the best dinner deal in town. Heads up: it's cash only. ATM on premises.

Good Pizza, which is needed after a while dancing and drinking at the Grove...

Salty food, nasty dude.

Great place to eat. Really exceed my expectative. I really totally recommend it. A down side is they are cash only.

Great staff! Pizza and entrees are delicious. Always grab a slice before getting on the ferry back to shore..

Best pizza in Fire Island

Great food Good service great staff.

Frank, AJ, and Joseph always helpful and friendly. All that work there are great, forgot some names, sorry. Pizza is great, as are all the other Italian dishes. Raul makes delicious daily specials. Great food and reasonably priced.

Enjoyful

Inviting environment

Good pizza and good dinners.

The pizza is always good

The service the staff make feel special

If your at Cherry Grove ocean walk in Fire Island, Cherry Grove Pizza is the place to go. I greeted by the really nice waitress, who had a smile the whole time. She also made sure I got everything I needed and checked up on me to make sure a comfortable amount of times. I asked what she recommended, so I decided to go with the chicken hero. It was delicious, hot sub, 12’ and fulfilling. The cheese was on point and the bread was not hard on the ends and the chicken was perfect as expected. Great cooks. The other waitress was very nice, as I got up from my table she asked if everything was okay and if needed anything. I did not only enjoy my food but the service inside and out was 5star. I love and will definitely go back.

Great Pizza, friendly staff!

Food was great but service was a little slow

Awesome pizza!

Always delicious pizza and the lasagna is the bomb

Food is ok. Service is slow but friendly. Nice seating.

A gorgeous pizzeria located within the Cherry Grove community. Accessible by Sayville ferry only. Outdoor dining in beautiful dining areas surrounded by beautiful floral. Pizza is our of this world.

Awesome pizza and breakfast pizza, no other like it!!

The cheeseburger bacon pizza is a must 😍😍😍

Great pizza and good prices (for Fire Island) Fun outdoor dining

Terrible food, terrible prices

The pizza was delish, get the bacon cheeseburger Chile 🤤

Very nice and accommodating staff. Excellent food. Their meatvamea are as good as my mom's recipe!

Excellent pizza and friendly staff.

Food and service are always great.

the absolute best special and pizza you can ask for ...I dont eat carbs all week so I can Indulge on weekends!

Best Pizza you can find on Long Island!

Amazing pizza!